Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dan Pace's avatar

I love the bit on fitness:

"Even in his day, people would look to physicians to cure their souls. “Every man wishes to make money to give to the doctors, destroyers of life: they therefore ought to be rich… Shun physicians because their drugs are a kind of alchemy, he who takes medicine is ill-advised.” Da Vinci sees the importance in fitness and physical exercise to overall health."

I've been thinking about this a lot lately, and while in general I share Leo's distaste for docs, I've tried to refine my bias.

Western medicine excels at reacting to contact: Broken arm? solved. Heart attack? fixed. In my opinion, it struggles with treating causes or thinking about health holistically, though, rather than simply responding to symptoms, and the system frequently looks very profit focused. It often seems to disdain cheap or natural remedies and instead prefer newer (and more expensive) options. I suspect this is what Da Vinci was opposed to.

I think what Da Vinci is recommending is a more holistic approach to health that is driven by listening to our bodies and living in a manner that's conducive to good health. I try to do that, but it's increasingly clear to me as I age that I'm not always sure how to achieve 'health.' This has led me to talking to experts to fill the gaps in my knowledge. Maybe Da Vinci would disagree with me, but I don't think we should always discount the 'men of letters.' Sometimes our own observations lead us in directions that are counter to where we want to be.

Instead, I think we take experts' recommendations as one more data point to use in our own efforts to figure out how to live. The trick, as Da Vinci points out elsewhere, is figuring out how to synthesize all of the seemingly unrelated information into a comprehensive understanding of fitness and a plan to achieve it, and then to leverage that fitness into increased capability elsewhere in life.

Or maybe I'm just another dude giving money away to quacks and snake oil salesmen. That's certainly possible too!

No posts

Ready for more?